American Home Shield VS First American Home Warranty

 Get an Instant Quote

American Home Shield Review

American Home Shield

Our Score: 8.7

User Score: 8.7

Total User Votes: 552










American Home Shield Company Details:

Price:
$125 - $500+

Deductable:
$75-125

Effective:
15 days after enrollment

Coverage:
Nationwide

Time in Business:
43 Years

BBB Rating:
A+

Site Security:
Yes

Phone Number:
1-800-776-4663

Fax Number:
None

CEO:
Mark Barry

Hours:
24/7

Promo Code:
None

Address: 889 Ridge Lake Blvd.
Memphis, TN 38120

First American Home Warranty Review

 Get an Instant Quote
First American Home Warranty

Our Score: 9.5

User Score: 8.6

Total User Votes: 412










First American Home Warranty Company Details:

Price:
$288-468

Deductible:
$65-75

Effective:
30 days after enrollment

Coverage:
Nationwide

Time in Business:
25 Years

BBB Rating:
A-

Site Security:
Yes

Phone Number:
1-800-992-3400

Fax Number:
1-800-772-1151

CEO:
Larry Davidson

Hours:
24/7

Promo Code:
None

Address: P.O. Box 7248 Santa Rosa, CA 95407

Let’s make an in-depth American Home Shield vs First America Home Warranty comparison. American Home Shield is providing service in 49 states for 1.4 million customers. The First American Home Warranty on the other hand has been around for a quarter of a century. It’s difficult to choose the right home warranty, hopefully by the end of this article we will help you make up your mind. Both companies are very well recognized and successful, but which one gets the nod?

Quick Overview

American Home Shield has a flexible and a personalized plan, this makes them stand out from the rest of the competition, and it allows you to pick the home items you’d like to insure. You also have the opportunity to insure a range of home systems and appliances, American Home Shield covers 21 types of home systems, and you can also build your own plan. First American Home Warranty offers reliable, innovative, and affordable warranty plans. They are responsible for the maintenance and repair of the home at any period of time. The repair costs are also consider cheap and their service is 24/7 available, that gives you a sense of security. During the period of listing and escrow, you as a seller are guaranteed the protection against expensive and costly repairs. Real estate professionals have praised First American Home Warranty for their considerations to the sellers.

Home Protection Highlights

American Home Shield offers a unique appliance discount program, it gives you the opportunity to purchase new appliances at great discounts. You are also assisted in finding a contractor, AHS will provide you with a range of pre-screened professionals. American Home Shield has a great website, you can find free helpful tips at any time. First American Home Warranty offers coverage for a year, there is an additional coverage when it comes to home appliances. You can get assistance from First American Home Warranty for practically anything, even something as redundant as a garbage disposal. FAHW also provides services in cases of natural disasters such as floods and fire breakouts.

Company Plans and Contract

American Home Shield offers several plans, there is the Combo Home Warranty Plan, Build Your Own Home Warranty Plan, The Systems Warranty Plan, The Appliance Warranty Plan, Optional Add-ons, and Service Call Free. Let’s take a greater look into each and every one of them:- The Combo Home Warranty Plan: We start with the most popular one, it covers everything from both the Appliance and the Systems plans.- Build Your Own Home Warranty Plan: Here you get a lot of flexibility, choose 10 or more item you need covered and you are set.- The Systems Warranty Plan: This particular plan offers repair and/or replacement of a number of domestic systems.- The Appliance Warranty Plan: Similar to The Systems Warranty Plan except it covers appliances instead.- Optional Add-ons: If none of the aforementioned plans is suited for you, there is an add-on option that might intrigue you.- Service Call Free: You get services from an electrician, plumber, etc. There are few limitations with First American Home Warranty that you should be familiar with, the cost and the extra charges might be relatively higher. When a contractor comes to your home for repair and replacements, they check the cause for the damage, if it is caused by the lack of care from the owner, services might be declined.

Company Complaints and Cons

With American Home Shield, some of the appliances might not be replaced, there are some additional charges after requesting the combo and the systems plan. There are also some “hidden” charges that you should be aware of, read the contract carefully. First American Home Warranty offers lower deductible than many competitors, a seller’s plan that prevents your listing from becoming a remodel, and most importantly, First American Home Warranty is well established and experienced.

Which Company is Worth It?

American Home Shield provides the best service, it provides you with a number of choices, which gives you great flexibility which is very important especially if it’s your first time insuring appliances. Even though opinions about First American Home Warranty show some negative feedback, the overall impression is positive. FAHW has been one of the top home warranty companies for 25 years.

At the end of the day, we give the nod to American Home Shield. If you end up choosing First American Home Warranty instead, it won’t come as a big surprise, they are both great companies that are worth considering.